Showing posts with label WANE 15. Show all posts
Showing posts with label WANE 15. Show all posts

Thursday, March 20, 2025

Opportunity

Here's an opportunity for our local media to do their jobs.

A study was commissioned to determine if a 60 million dollar "Field House" should be built on the old OmniSource property north of downtown. 

Here's how WANE-15 portrays the funding of the "study":


And here's how the Journal Gazette, Fort Wayne's last remaining daily print journalists, reported on who paid for the "study":

It would be nice if our local journalists could get clarification on who exactly paid for the research and whether taxpayer money was involved.

Why is this important? 

If the City paid for the study, the credibility of the findings of the study/report could be suspect and seen as a justification for moving the project forward.  

On the other hand, if the study/report were paid for by an independent group or organization, those results might be viewed as more "objective".

So, the Maven will wait for the clarification. 

 



Friday, November 1, 2024

Political Yard Sign Violence/Vandalism

If you watch the local TV news, one would think that political yard sign vandalism only happens to Democrats and only happens in communities outside the city of Fort Wayne. 


The Maven does not doubt that these incidents happen. But the Maven wonders why it's only the supporters of one political party that seem to get the coverage.

Are these people better at involving the media? 

Do the supporters of the other political party not experience this vandalism?

Do incidents of political sign vandalism/violence only happen in areas away from the Fort Wayne city center?

Just seems odd.  







Wednesday, October 30, 2024

Click-Bait Frustrations

Click-bait is annoying as hell. Click-bait also means revenue. 

Local TV news social media is no stranger to click-bait news stories. Usually, these stories are gut-wrenching tales of death and despair that tug on the heartstrings of even the most hardened viewers/readers. Every time you click on one of them it means more revenue and profits for the out-of-town corporations that own our local TV stations.

WPTA ABC 21Alive seems to be the worst offender, but WANE-15 also runs these stories on their social media platforms. But, WANE-15 deserves credit for offering the reader/viewer a bit more information.

Below, note, that the WPTA ABC 21Alive story, by lack of identification, implies that it occurred here, in Fort Wayne. But that's not true. The story that WPTA ABC 21Alive features didn't even happen in the US. It's from Nova Scotia, in Canada. 


WANE-15 wisely drops a hint to readers/viewers that the story they feature occurred in Kansas. 

Kudos to WANE-15 for helping readers/viewers make wise decisions on what they choose to click on, and what to scroll by. 


Friday, October 18, 2024

Balanced? Maybe, Maybe Not


WANE-15 aired a story a few days ago (October 15) alleging political yard sign vandalism in Van Wert, Ohio.

Here's a link to the story: https://www.wane.com/top-stories/van-wert-residents-targeted-for-having-harris-yard-signs/

It's a standard story during election time. Vandalism to political yard signs has been with us since, well, the first political yard sign appeared back in the 19th century. What made the WANE-15 report curious was that it implied that only signs supporting the Democratic Party presidential candidates were stolen/trashed. The local chairman of the Democrats was featured making comments about the vandalism, including concerns that residents were living in a fearful environment. 

The Maven wonders why no one contacted local Republican party officials to ask if their supporters' signs were damaged or stolen. Does the Republican chairman in Van Wert believe his supporters live in a fearful environment?

The Maven has no issue with the accuracy of the story, but does have concerns about "balance". 

Only interviewing the Democrat Party chairperson, and promoting a local Democratic Party event including time, location and ticket price information seems, in the Maven's opinion, to unbalance the story.

Please note: the ticket price information for the Van Wert Democratic Party event is only mentioned in the "live" report (imbedded in the story) and does not appear in the text of the story as published on WANE.COM. 


Thursday, October 10, 2024

Leaving CBS News Behind...

The Maven has struggled with watching CBS News for quite a while.

Something is wrong with the operation. There has been a less-than-subtle shift from doing journalism to advancing an agenda. Reading the article linked below was the final straw. 

CBS News is broken and the Maven is abandoning them. 

Here's the link to The Free Press story:

https://www.thefp.com/p/does-cbs-news-know-where-jerusalem


Tuesday, August 6, 2024

Two Good Ones Get Away...

Two outstanding individuals who added a good dose of professionalism to an otherwise desert of media mediocrity are leaving town for a larger market. 

The Maven bids a sincere farewell to WANE-15's Emily Dwire and Rex Smith.

 


The Maven has never had the pleasure of meeting Rex, but has talked with Emily on the phone a few times. She was always bright and helpful. Rex's work on air and in the anchor chair was always top-notch.

The Maven wishes Emily and Rex much success in the next chapter of their lives and careers. 

Sunday, January 21, 2024

Those Rand McNally Moments


Many reading this blog will have no idea who the gentleman in the meme is, but his message conveys the frustration of many in the mass audience. If you work here, you should, at the least, have a handle on local geography. 


Besides jumbling facts and figures (which they contort and confuse regularly), it appears those young "journalists" on our nightly newscasts, er, shows (sorry), seem to have no understanding of local geography. 


The Maven has a few examples:


The intersection of Broadway and Taylor, in the shadow of the transformative Electric Works project, wreaks havoc with the kids in the newsroom. Some say it's downtown, south of downtown, or west of downtown. A map would have been helpful on this one. Hint (it's southwest of downtown).



It's not just Fort Wayne geography that confuses the newsrooms. Hoosier state geography is also a mystery. Linton is a pleasant little town southwest of Indianapolis.



The Journal Gazette, a fixture in downtown for more than a century, is also confused about what downtown means. For the record, 2213 Fox Avenue is southwest of downtown.



What is it about Broadway that confuses these young skulls full of mush? It's still southwest. Hasn't changed in years.



Another example of misidentifying location. The 400 block of Poplar is South of Washington/Jefferson, and West of Calhoun (the traditional divisions on NE, SE, SW, and NW as used by the City of Fort Wayne). This makes it Southwest...but, apparently WPTAABC21Alive has other ideas...



So, what's the big deal you say. Besides the property damage caused by irate viewers hurling the shoes, dentures, and small animals at TV screens across the tristate region...these "errors" chip away at local TV's already dwindling credibility.





Friday, December 29, 2023

The Problem With Breaking News...it's almost always broken

It started out as a shooting at the Bluffton Walmart.

Then it was a shooting at an apartment complex near the Bluffton Walmart.

Briefly, it was a stabbing at an apartment complex near the Bluffton Walmart. 

Then it was a beating at an apartment complex near the Bluffton Walmart. 

Then law enforcement had the final word.


WANE-15 puts it to bed:






Sunday, September 17, 2023

Media Gossip: Two Rumors


A couple of rumors from the local media rumor mill. One substantiated, one not.

Substantiated: The Maven has been copied on an email string that indicates that former WANE-15 anchor Heather Heron will be joining the WPTA ABC21Alive operation sometime around the end of September.

Unsubstantiated: Multiple tips about former WPTA ABC21Alive anchor Brien McElhatten moving into the anchor chair at FOX55's news operation in the coming months. Tipsters are conjecturing that Brien is waiting out a non-compete clause in his contract if one exists and is enforceable. In the meantime, he's reportedly enjoying the benefits of being a stay-at-home dad. 

Stay tuned...as they say...

Thursday, August 24, 2023

The Weather Extremeists


The reality is that it's going to be really hot and humid today. 

The fallacy is that at some point this afternoon, we will all suddenly burst into flames if we don't follow the "helpful" (read PANIC) warnings coming from the local TV newsrooms.

The two leading news operations have stoked panic by declaring today as a "15 Fury Alert Day" and a "First Alert Day". Those carefully-researched and focus-group-tested phrases are designed to imply that any exposure to the heat and humidity of the afternoon will put our lives in serious danger unless we stay at home and lock ourselves in our climate-controlled "safe spaces" while watching their continuous coverage we can count on interspersed with commercials from those annoying Peterman Brothers HVAC charlatans claiming the "furnace is free" (hint-it is not free). 
(Yes, it's a run-on sentence). 

We see this type of weather hype most often in the winter months when we are told an impending Friday snowstorm could bring us 12-18 inches of snow. As the days approach for the "storm of the century", the snow totals are "revised" Tuesday to 6-8 inches, then Wednesday it's forecast 4-6 inches. Finally, on Friday, most of us are treated to a light dusting of snow or just some flurries. "We sure dodged a bullet on that one, whew"! they will proudly exclaim.

All of this codswallop is by design. 

Somewhere in the last 10 years, TV stations quit calling their nightly news presentations "newscasts" and began to call them "shows". In essence, PT Barnum has replaced Ed Murrow. Somewhere along the line TV news operations embraced the ignorant idea that their viewing audiences consist of barely literate, mouth-breathing fools whose attention spans are measured in milliseconds. Therefore, to engage their audience, modern-day journalistic operations feel they have to present their "shows' with all the "flash/bang fireworks subtly" of a Trump MAGA rally. 

One of the most annoying aspects of today's situation is the premise that these weather extremes are somehow "new" and have "never been experienced" by mankind before. Kids, this is Indiana. This is August. It gets hot and humid every year, some years more than others. 

Why is this seemingly new to those on the TV? One explanation is that those who choose and present what we see on TV were born after 1999. The only Fort Wayne mayors they remember are Graham Richard and Tom Henry. So, with little real-world experience, a good old Hoosier heatwave is something to behold and fear. They forget that most people in the audience lived a portion of their lives without air conditioning in their homes, workplaces, and schools. They are unaware that cell phones and the internet did not exist until their generation. They also forget that the parents and grandparents of their current audience worked in the fields and factories in heat and cold without the benefit of modern HVAC technology...unlike the coddled young "journalists" of today who matriculated their way through Ball State in those air-conditioned dorms and classrooms. 

It's about perspective and understanding and respecting the audience. 

It's going to be hot today. Just like any extremely hot August day.
 
The weather information is necessary, but the hype is not. 



Tuesday, October 25, 2022

Did We View The Same Meeting?

Fort Wayne City Councilman Jason Arp's attempt at a political stunt died a quick death at the Council table. But, local media seems to have a difference of opinion on just how that happened. 

According to the kids at WANE 15:

WPTA 21Alive/Fort Wayne NBC also got it wrong: (there was no vote, kids)


Here's what the Journal Gazette reported (and what the Media Maven witnessed at the meeting):


Maybe, Robert's Rules of Order is not required reading at Ball State for the TV folks.

The WANE-15 story was updated to reflect the correct information. Bravo.

And for those who missed it, the original WANE TV story is posted below followed by the WPTA ABC21Alive/Fort Wayne NBC story (since the Maven has been accused of making this stuff up).

‘Totally inappropriate:’ City Council shoots down Arp

by: Clayton McMahan

Posted: Oct 25, 2022 / 04:53 PM EDT

Updated: Oct 25, 2022 / 11:10 PM EDT

SHARE

FORT WAYNE, Ind. (WANE) — Fort Wayne City Council President Jason Arp announced plans to propose cuts to Mayor Tom Henry’s operating budget ahead of Tuesday’s City Council meeting.

Arp’s statement said under the proposition, the budget would not be restored until “all of the information requests have been fulfilled.”

Although Mayor Henry recently answered a list of questions previously posed by Councilman Arp, Arp and WANE 15 have requested video evidence from the Oct. 8 crash, which still has not been released.

Mayor Henry responds to questions posed by Councilman Jason Arp

Here is Councilman Arp’s full statement regarding the city budget:

“At tonight’s Council meeting I am putting forth cuts to the Mayor’s operating budget.  As City Council President, I have been working with our attorneys and staff to ensure questions related to the incident that occurred October 8th have been answered.  Many of the questions we have asked were answered in a timely manner, however we have asked that the video evidence from the night of the event be preserved for Council’s review in order to conclude our inquiry into the matter.  We have been told that the video evidence will not be available until the case is closed upon sentencing.  While I have confidence that our request will be granted in a timely manner, I am requesting a cut of the Mayor’s Office operating budget. The budget would then be restored once all of the information requests have been fulfilled.  Budgetary action is one of the Council’s few means of recourse to ensure accountability.  We are hoping we will know the week of November 9th and that we will be able to promptly restore these budget items.”

At the meeting, City Council voted 8-1 to not move forward with Arp’s proposal to cut Mayor Henry’s operating budget.

Arp was the only one who voted in favor of the proposal.

Multiple councilmembers, including Geoff Paddock and Michelle Chambers, expressed their feelings on the proposal at the meeting and felt that it was not necessary.

“I will not support any effort that would hold the Mayor’s office or his staff or his operations hostage,” Paddock said.

Chambers said she would not support a proposal that would use the budget as a “weapon.”

“I don’t believe that it is our place to leverage and weaponize a budget to deal with a situation that is not related to the budget,” Chambers said.

Mayor Henry released a statement after the meeting concluded:

Fort Wayne continues to experience growth and success, and tonight’s passage by City Council of the budget for 2023 demonstrates we’re positioned for even better days ahead for our community. Fiscal discipline is critical as we work together to meet the needs, wants and desires of residents, neighborhoods and businesses. We’re looking forward to a productive 2023 with initiatives planned for every quadrant that will make a lasting and meaningful difference. Next year will bring record investments for neighborhood infrastructure and a continued commitment to public safety and our parks. By working together, we’ll be able to continue the positive momentum that we’ve built in Fort Wayne as a point of destination to live, work and play.

The WPTA ABC21Alive/Fort Wayne's NBC Story:

By Alex Null

Published: Oct. 25, 2022 at 11:42 PM EDT|Updated: 2 hours ago

FORT WAYNE, Ind. (WPTA) - Late Tuesday afternoon, City Council president Jason Arp released a statement saying he proposed budget cuts for the mayor’s office, because, he says, more evidence from the mayor’s recent crash and OWI arrest needs to come out. Namely, police body camera video.

Arp recently penned a letter to the city attorney, asking that several questions be answered that primarily had to do with whether taxpayers would have to foot the bill for damages caused by the crash.

The mayor later said he would pay for all damages involved.

Read Arp’s statement, in full, below:

“At tonight’s Council meeting I am putting forth cuts to the Mayor’s operating budget. As City Council President, I have been working with our attorneys and staff to ensure questions related to the incident that occurred October 8th have been answered. Many of the questions we have asked were answered in a timely manner, however we have asked that the video evidence from the night of the event be preserved for Council’s review in order to conclude our inquiry into the matter. We have been told that the video evidence will not be available until the case is closed upon sentencing.

While I have confidence that our request will be granted in a timely manner, I am requesting a cut of the Mayor’s Office operating budget. The budget would then be restored once all of the information requests have been fulfilled. Budgetary action is one of the Council’s few means of recourse to ensure accountability. We are hoping we will know the week of November 9th and that we will be able to promptly restore these budget items.”

- Councilman Arp

The mayor’s sentencing date is set for November 7th.

City council discussed and voted on Arp’s proposal Tuesday evening, with most council members voting against it. They said budget cuts normally take place while approving budgets, and this move was not necessary.

“For me, the budget cut to cut the mayor’s entire budget was not appropriate.,” Democratic Councilwoman Michelle Chambers said. “I felt like that was being used as a weapon to achieve some answers to questions that have been answered already. I don’t believe it is our place to leverage and weaponize a budget to deal with a situation that is not related to the budget.”

Chambers also said for any council member to ask for the police body cam video is inappropriate, because it’s not their responsibility to do so. Fellow democratic councilman Geoff Paddock said he agreed.

“I did disagree with his cuts tonight. I think obviously a majority of us did, feeling it was not appropriate to go through line item by line item on the mayor’s budget, particularly when there is no rhyme or reason to that,” Paddock said.

Council did approve the overall city budget for next year at the meeting. Following the vote, a statement from Mayor Tom Henry was released, and says in full:

“Fort Wayne continues to experience growth and success, and tonight’s passage by City Council of the budget for 2023 demonstrates we’re positioned for even better days ahead for our community. Fiscal discipline is critical as we work together to meet the needs, wants and desires of residents, neighborhoods and businesses. We’re looking forward to a productive 2023 with initiatives planned for every quadrant that will make a lasting and meaningful difference.

Next year will bring record investments for neighborhood infrastructure and a continued commitment to public safety and our parks. By working together, we’ll be able to continue the positive momentum that we’ve built in Fort Wayne as a point of destination to live, work and play.”

- Mayor Tom Henry

Copyright 2022 WPTA. All rights reserved.



Tuesday, August 16, 2022

Kudos for WANE-15

The Maven wants to officially recognize WANE-15 for a news story that got results for people being screwed-over and for putting the questionable actions of Fort Wayne City Utilities in an unpleasant spotlight. 

As a side note, shame on Fort Wayne City Utilities for their heavy-handed tactic in this story. 

Thursday, June 2, 2022

Confusing Numbers

Introducing this story today, the WANE-15 anchor stated: "according to Apartmentlist.com, rent has risen by 10% in Fort Wayne..."

But that's not what WANE-15 reported back in March, when a 40% increase in rent was referred to as "doubling". Leaving the faulty TV reporter math aside, viewers might be confused to what the "real" number is. 


The real answer is "it depends". 

It depends on what "expert" the media uses as a source, and often many numerical and statistical observations suffer from the curse of "apples" and "oranges". 

In the end, these "explanations" and analytical exercises do little to help those affected understand or solve the problems they face.  




Sunday, October 7, 2018

What's So Funny?

The Maven wonders what was in the coffee (or the brownies), as the crew of WANE 15's First News Saturday conducted what could only be called a "giggle-fest" Saturday morning (10/6/18)



While bright smiles and an upbeat attitude work well for morning programs, the Maven noted that the atmosphere was more than just jovial for the morning broadcast as both anchors seemed to be enjoying a joke not shared with the audience. 



The fun and frivolity weren't confined to just the West State studios, WANE 15's reporter-ette reporting live from a farmer's market seemed to get caught up in the fun. At one point, her giggles became so distracting that she actually turned her back on the camera and guest, to compose herself and then wrapped up her reported as she fought back the giggles. 



Now, the Maven is known to enjoy a good laugh, but really, kids. 

What was so damn funny that you couldn't share with the audience? 

You left us out. The least you could have done is to share those brownies.