Tuesday, May 25, 2021

Mass Shooting. Guaranteed Headline-grabber

When the WANE-15 News app alerted about a MASS SHOOTING Saturday night, the Maven quickly recalled the carnage at Indianapolis' Fed Ex facility recently where a single gunman killed 8 people. 
As more details emerged from Saturday night's shooting, an innocent woman, sleeping in her apartment had died by a stray bullet, and 4 others were injured due to what appeared to be a parking lot gunfight at the Villages of Hanna/Eden Green apartments.
While the death of anyone is tragic, one wonders why WANE-15 chose to call the tragedy a MASS SHOOTING
For the record, no other Fort Wayne media outlet called Saturday's loss of life a MASS SHOOTING. WPTA ABC21 and their red-headed stepchild Fort Wayne's NBC characterized the event as a GUN FIGHT. WOWO 1190 radio and the Journal-Gazette merely labeled it a SHOOTING
The Maven wonders why WANE-15 has suddenly taken to sensationalizing local tragedies, most recently explicitly describing a murdered toddler's injuries with the words "heart ripped in half". Is this a directive from Media Giant Nextar (WANE-15's owner) or just an effort to gain more ratings and increase profits by emotionalizing and event that takes a life? We may never know. 
As for the term MASS SHOOTING, there appears to be no quantifiable definition. 
Following the MASS SHOOTING at the Indy Fed Ex facility, Indy's WTHR 13 published and excellent story attempting to explain the use of the term. 
"Rand Company research found a common approach has been to set a casualty threshold of "four fatalities by firearm, excluding the offender or offenders." Research can rely on fatality data captured in administrative reports and, frequently, media."
So, absent a well-defined definition of MASS SHOOTING, the Rand research puts it best: 
"A gray area arises when media, researchers, academics and law enforcement agencies use different definitions of mass shootings for their separate purposes."
In WANE-15's case, Saturday night's tragedy is a MASS SHOOTING, because it serves WANE-15's purposes. 

Find the WTHR 13 story here:

Wednesday, May 19, 2021

If It Bleeds, It Leads

"If It Bleeds, It Leads" is an old news business phrase to describe how sensationalizing a tragic story will reward the news outlet with higher ratings, higher readership, and increased profits.

Today's tragic story of the murder of 17-month-old Aiden Mishawn Clark was reported by Fort Wayne local media. 

Most media outlets played it straight and reported the facts...and one chose to sensationalize, and exploit the child's death. Can you spot the one story that's not like the others? 


From WPTA ABC21:


From the Journal Gazette:


From WANE-15:


And the often-forgotten WFFT 55:


Which of these news stories would you be most likely NOT choose to read and/or explain to your kids? 

 

Tuesday, May 11, 2021

Who Is At Fault?

A dead body is reported to the police. They investigate. PIO makes a statement based on conjecture.

Neophyte reporter reports the remark as fact. 

Days later the Coroner's investigation proves the PIO's statement and reporter's story totally incorrect.

Who gets a reprimand? Or does anyone?


Read paragraphs 3 and 4 of the WANE TV story. You can find it here: 




Sunday, May 2, 2021

Ten More Things I Learned From Local Media

11. Automobiles are being fined, apparently not the drivers of the cars. One would think that a human would be in a better position to pay the fine, than an inanimate object like a car...but if WANE TV says it, it must be true. 



12. That big church in Paris, France is interchangeable with that big university in South Bend, Indiana. 



13. Any FUBAR is always blamed on technology. It's easier than taking responsibility, unless an advertising sponsor is involved. Then, an intern is the culprit. (unless the intern is related to the sponsor).



14. If you criticize local media on their Facebook page or other social media, they will either ban you from the page, or will get their feelings hurt, have a good cry, and then withdraw to their "safe place" because what you said is "hurtful". Also note, that WPTA ABC21 journalistic standards for a news cast on the air, and a live social media broadcast are different. So, the jerky camera shots plus the hyperventilated rumor and conjecture during Facebook live reports are not only excused, they are celebrated?


15. Hands, feet, and guns are routinely used by criminals in the commission of a crime. Who knew?


16. If a listener asks you a question about a station promotion, and you don't know the answer, don't bother the K105 promotion director...just tell the listener to "lighten up". I'm sure the listener will remember your helpful text exchange if they ever have to fill out an Arbitron ratings diary. 


17. While you slept, WANE TV moved Mercer County, Ohio across the line into Indiana. 


18. According to WFFT, Fort Wayne City Utilities also offers natural gas and electricity. Who knew?


19. According to the kids in the WOWO news room, being accused of murder makes one a murderer...even before there's a trial. 



20. Glenbrook Mall must have good self-esteem, if during a power outage, they can remain calm and COMPOSED. 




More to come...